Table of Contents
The Mazda RX-8, known for its unique rotary engine, has become a popular platform for engine swaps, particularly with the LS engine family. Among the various options, builders often debate between forced induction and naturally aspirated LS engines. This article compares these two approaches regarding power, cost, and reliability.
Understanding LS Engines
LS engines, part of General Motors’ Gen III and IV small-block V8 family, are renowned for their performance and adaptability. They have gained a solid reputation in the automotive community, especially in the context of engine swaps.
Forced Induction LS Engines
Forced induction refers to the use of a supercharger or turbocharger to increase the engine’s air intake, thereby boosting power output. This method has become increasingly popular among RX-8 builders.
Power Output
One of the main advantages of forced induction is the significant increase in power. By compressing the air entering the engine, builders can achieve higher horsepower and torque figures.
- Supercharged LS engines can produce between 500 to 700 horsepower.
- Turbocharged LS engines can exceed 800 horsepower with the right setup.
Cost Considerations
While the performance gains are enticing, the cost of forced induction setups can be substantial. Components such as superchargers, turbochargers, intercoolers, and additional tuning are necessary to maximize performance.
- Supercharger kits can range from $5,000 to $10,000.
- Turbocharger kits can start around $3,000 and go upwards of $10,000.
Reliability Factors
Forced induction systems can put additional strain on engine components. Proper tuning and quality parts are crucial to maintaining reliability. However, the risk of engine failure increases with higher power outputs.
Naturally Aspirated LS Engines
Naturally aspirated LS engines, on the other hand, rely solely on atmospheric pressure to draw air into the engine. This approach has its own set of advantages and disadvantages.
Power Output
Naturally aspirated engines typically produce less power compared to their forced induction counterparts. However, they can still deliver impressive performance, especially when built for high RPMs.
- Common naturally aspirated LS builds range from 350 to 500 horsepower.
- High-performance naturally aspirated builds can reach up to 600 horsepower.
Cost Considerations
The cost of building a naturally aspirated LS engine can be more manageable than a forced induction setup. Fewer components and simpler tuning requirements often lead to lower overall costs.
- Basic naturally aspirated builds can start around $2,500.
- High-performance builds may range from $4,000 to $8,000.
Reliability Factors
Naturally aspirated engines generally offer better reliability due to lower stress levels on engine components. With fewer parts to fail, they can be a more dependable choice for daily drivers.
Comparing Key Aspects
- Power: Forced induction provides higher power potential.
- Cost: Naturally aspirated builds are typically less expensive.
- Reliability: Naturally aspirated engines tend to be more reliable under normal use.
Conclusion
Choosing between a forced induction and naturally aspirated LS engine for an RX-8 build ultimately depends on the builder’s goals, budget, and intended use. Both options have their merits, and understanding the differences can help make an informed decision.