Table of Contents
The world of turbochargers can be complex and overwhelming, especially for those looking to enhance the performance of their Honda S2000. In this article, we will compare two popular options: the Precision Turbo 5857 and the Edelbrock E-Force. Both turbos have their unique features and benefits, making them suitable for different types of builds and driving styles.
Overview of the Precision Turbo 5857
The Precision Turbo 5857 is known for its efficiency and versatility. This turbo is designed to provide excellent spool characteristics while maintaining high power output. It is a popular choice among S2000 enthusiasts looking for a balance between street and track performance.
- Compressor Size: 57mm
- Turbine Size: 76mm
- Max Power: Up to 600 horsepower
- Boost Range: 20-30 PSI
Overview of the Edelbrock E-Force
The Edelbrock E-Force supercharger is another popular option for S2000 builds. Unlike traditional turbochargers, superchargers provide immediate power delivery and are often easier to install. The E-Force is designed to maximize performance while ensuring reliability and drivability.
- Type: Supercharger
- Max Power: Up to 500 horsepower
- Boost Pressure: Up to 10 PSI
- Installation: Relatively straightforward
Performance Comparison
When comparing the Precision Turbo 5857 and the Edelbrock E-Force, several factors come into play, including power delivery, spool time, and overall driving experience. Understanding these differences can help you make an informed decision based on your specific build and driving style.
Power Delivery
The Precision Turbo 5857 is known for its ability to deliver power smoothly across a wide RPM range. This turbo allows for a more linear power band, which can be beneficial for track use. In contrast, the Edelbrock E-Force provides immediate power, making it ideal for street driving where quick acceleration is desired.
Spool Time
Spool time is a critical factor in turbo performance. The Precision Turbo 5857 offers quick spool characteristics, allowing it to reach full boost at lower RPMs. This feature makes it suitable for drivers who want responsive power delivery. On the other hand, the Edelbrock E-Force’s supercharging mechanism provides instant boost, eliminating any lag that can be associated with turbochargers.
Driving Experience
The driving experience between these two options can vary significantly. The Precision Turbo 5857 provides a more dynamic driving experience, especially on the track, where its power can be fully utilized. The Edelbrock E-Force, with its instant power delivery, is more suited for daily driving, offering a fun and engaging experience without the need for high RPMs.
Installation Considerations
Installation is a crucial aspect to consider when choosing between the Precision Turbo 5857 and the Edelbrock E-Force. Each option has its own requirements and complexities that can affect your overall build process.
Precision Turbo 5857 Installation
Installing the Precision Turbo 5857 may require more modifications to your S2000, including custom piping and possibly upgrading other engine components to handle the increased power. This can lead to a more involved installation process, which may be a consideration for those less experienced with turbo setups.
Edelbrock E-Force Installation
The Edelbrock E-Force is designed for easier installation, often requiring fewer modifications. This can make it a more appealing choice for those looking for a straightforward upgrade without extensive mechanical work. However, it is essential to ensure that your S2000 is compatible with the supercharger system.
Cost Considerations
Cost is always a factor when choosing performance parts. Both the Precision Turbo 5857 and the Edelbrock E-Force come with their own price tags, which can vary based on the retailer and any additional components needed for installation.
Precision Turbo 5857 Pricing
The Precision Turbo 5857 typically falls within a higher price range due to its advanced technology and performance capabilities. Additionally, you may need to budget for supporting modifications, which can increase the overall cost of your build.
Edelbrock E-Force Pricing
The Edelbrock E-Force is often priced more competitively, making it an attractive option for those on a budget. The easier installation may also save you money on labor costs if you choose to have a professional install it.
Conclusion
In summary, both the Precision Turbo 5857 and the Edelbrock E-Force offer unique advantages for S2000 builds. Your choice will ultimately depend on your goals, whether you prioritize high-end power, installation ease, or overall driving experience. Understanding the differences between these two options can help you make the best decision for your performance needs.